How to Write Down Your Lending Criteria Before You Automate Underwriting

Updated November 5, 2026: corrected for accuracy.

To write lending criteria that software or a second reviewer can apply the same way, turn each judgment call into a testable rule with defined terms and named data sources. Cover property types, loan-to-value limits by collateral, required documents, exit plans and liquidity. Then write down how exceptions work, what stays with a person, and how the rules change.

Key Takeaways

  • Software and new reviewers can only apply rules that exist on paper.
  • A good rule names the data it uses, where that data comes from, and what result it produces.
  • Set loan-to-value limits separately for each collateral type you accept.
  • Write the exception process down, including who can approve one and what record it leaves.
  • Some judgment stays outside the rules on purpose, such as the borrower conversation and repeat-borrower history.
  • Date and version the criteria, and review them on a set schedule.

Related Topics

Why Write Down Criteria Before You Automate?

Many private lenders underwrite from experience. The rules live in the owner’s head. That works while one person reviews every file.

It stops working when a second person joins or when software enters the process. A tool cannot guess what you meant. A new reviewer will fill gaps with their own habits. Two reviewers reading the same file can then reach different answers.

Writing the criteria down fixes the target first. Automation comes second. The steps for bringing AI into underwriting all assume this written foundation already exists.

What Should a Written Criteria Document Cover?

Start with the questions you already ask on every file. Then give each one a written answer. Most private lending criteria fall into five groups.

  • Property types. List the collateral you accept and the collateral you decline. Name each type plainly so nobody has to interpret it.
  • Loan-to-value limits by collateral. Set a separate limit for each property type. State which value counts, such as an appraisal or another approved valuation, and how old it can be.
  • Documentation requirements. List every document a complete file needs. Note which ones apply only to entity borrowers or certain loan types.
  • Exit-plan expectations. Describe what an acceptable exit plan looks like, such as a sale or a refinance. Say what evidence supports it.
  • Liquidity checks. Define what counts as liquid funds, which statements prove them, and how you measure them against the loan.

The numbers in each rule are your business decision. This post does not recommend any limit. What matters is that the limit exists in writing.

How Do You Write a Rule Two People Read the Same Way?

A clear rule has three parts. It names the input. It names the source of that input. It states the result.

Compare two versions. “Borrower should have enough reserves” leaves room for opinion. A testable rule says which accounts count, which statements prove them, and what comparison decides pass or fail.

Define every term the first time it appears. Words like “seasoned,” “liquid” and “clean title” mean different things to different people. A short glossary at the top of the document removes that drift.

Test the draft before any software touches it. Give a past file to two reviewers. Ask each to apply only the written rules. Where they disagree, the wording needs work. The best practices for AI in underwriting build on criteria that pass this kind of test.

Some legal duties can attach to how criteria are written and applied. Those duties depend on loan type, state and loan purpose, business or consumer. Consult qualified legal counsel before you finalize criteria for any consumer-purpose lending.

How Should You Define Exceptions?

Every lender makes exceptions. The risk comes from exceptions nobody can trace later. A written exception process keeps flexibility without losing control.

Spell out four things. Who can approve an exception. Which rules can bend and which cannot. What written reason the approver must record. Where that record lives in the file.

Exceptions also feed future revisions. If the same rule gets bent again and again, the rule may be wrong. If an exception later causes trouble, the rule may have been right.

What Should Stay Outside the Written Rules?

Not every part of underwriting belongs in a rule. Some judgment works better with a person. Name those parts in the document so nobody tries to automate them by accident.

The borrower conversation is the clearest case. A direct talk can show whether the borrower understands the deal and has thought through the exit. No checklist captures that well.

Repeat-borrower history is another. A borrower with a long record of clean payoffs deserves a different kind of look. Software that treats every application the same will miss that context. Good servicing records make that history easier to review, as covered in servicing habits that earn repeat borrower business.

Unusual collateral also belongs here. When inputs are thin or odd, a score built on them can look confident and still be wrong. Route those files to a full human review. See underwriting decisions where human judgment beats AI for more on where people add the most.

How Do You Revise the Criteria Over Time?

Written criteria are a living document. Markets shift. Your appetite for risk changes. New collateral types come up.

Give every version a date and a version number. Record what changed and why. Keep old versions so you can see which rules applied to any past file.

Set a regular review schedule. Also set triggers for an early review, such as a new property type or a pattern of exceptions. Once you change the document, update any software that applies it. A tool running an old rule set is a common source of drift, as noted in common mistakes with AI in underwriting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need software to use written underwriting criteria?

No. Written criteria help a second reviewer or a new hire just as much as they help software. Many lenders write the criteria first and decide on tools later.

How detailed should loan-to-value rules be?

Detailed enough that two reviewers reach the same answer. That usually means a separate limit for each collateral type and a stated rule for which valuation counts. The limits themselves are your business decision.

Should the borrower conversation be scored?

One option is to keep it outside the scored rules. You can still record notes from the conversation in the file. That keeps the judgment visible without forcing it into a formula.

How should repeat borrowers be handled?

Decide in writing whether prior performance changes anything, and who can apply that judgment. Then record the reason in the file each time. This keeps relationship lending traceable.

Are there legal rules about how criteria are applied?

There can be. They depend on loan type, state and loan purpose, business or consumer. Consult qualified legal counsel about your own obligations.

How often should criteria be reviewed?

Pick a regular schedule that fits your volume. Also review early when you add a collateral type or notice repeated exceptions to the same rule.

Sources

  • Underwriting, fair lending and documentation requirements vary by loan type, state and loan purpose. Consult qualified legal counsel about your specific obligations.

Next Steps

If you want to talk about how clear origination files and payment records support a note through its whole life, we can help. Contact Note Servicing Center to start a conversation about your servicing needs.

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or compliance advice. Always consult a qualified attorney or advisor regarding your specific situation.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Disclaimer

The information provided in this article is for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, investment, tax, or professional advice. Note Servicing Center, Inc. is a licensed loan servicer and does not provide legal counsel, investment recommendations, or financial planning services. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client, fiduciary, or advisory relationship of any kind. Nothing in this article constitutes an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a recommendation regarding any security, promissory note, mortgage note, fractional interest, or other investment product. Any references to notes, yields, returns, or investment structures are illustrative and educational only. Past performance is not indicative of future results, and all investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Note investing, real estate transactions, and lending activities are subject to federal, state, and local laws that vary by jurisdiction and change over time. Before making any decision based on the information in this article, you should consult with a qualified attorney, licensed financial advisor, certified public accountant, or other appropriate professional who can evaluate your specific circumstances. Some articles on this site include hypothetical stories, examples, and scenarios created to illustrate concepts and demonstrate the types of situations Note Servicing Center, Inc. handles. Any names, companies, properties, and circumstances in these examples are fictitious or have been anonymized to protect confidentiality, and any resemblance to actual persons or entities is coincidental. These examples do not describe specific clients and do not guarantee any particular outcome. Some content may be created with the assistance of generative AI tools and may contain errors or omissions. While we make reasonable efforts to ensure the accuracy of the information presented, Note Servicing Center, Inc. makes no warranties or representations regarding the completeness, accuracy, or current applicability of any content. We disclaim all liability for actions taken or not taken in reliance on this article.